• Publish Your article
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Thursday, October 9, 2025
No Result
View All Result
UK Herald
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Sports
    England rugby stadium Twickenham given new name after more than 100 years in shock new deal

    England rugby stadium Twickenham given new name after more than 100 years in shock new deal

    Peter Morgan dead at 65: Former Wales and Lions rugby star who became a politician passes away as club pays tribute

    Peter Morgan dead at 65: Former Wales and Lions rugby star who became a politician passes away as club pays tribute

    Horse racing tips: Unexposed Group 1 contender can stun the big guns at 14-1

    Horse racing tips: Unexposed Group 1 contender can stun the big guns at 14-1

    Woman ‘raped seven times by two French rugby stars who left her riddled with bite marks & with horror injuries’

    Woman ‘raped seven times by two French rugby stars who left her riddled with bite marks & with horror injuries’

    Horse racing tips: Gary Moore’s charge can gain revenge after falling last time out

    Horse racing tips: Gary Moore’s charge can gain revenge after falling last time out

    Ian Buckett dead at 56: Former Wales rugby star who was ‘admired and feared equally’ dies as tributes pour in

    Ian Buckett dead at 56: Former Wales rugby star who was ‘admired and feared equally’ dies as tributes pour in

    Horse racing tips: Bash the bookies with these longshots including 9-1 fancy

    Horse racing tips: Bash the bookies with these longshots including 9-1 fancy

    Shayne Philpott dead at 58 – New Zealand All Blacks rugby legend dies after suffering ‘medical event’

    Shayne Philpott dead at 58 – New Zealand All Blacks rugby legend dies after suffering ‘medical event’

    Horse racing tips: This 7-1 chance appears to have been laid out for race he won last year

    Horse racing tips: This 7-1 chance appears to have been laid out for race he won last year

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • food
    • Health
    • Travel
    Major airline removes carry-on bag sizers from boarding gates

    Major airline removes carry-on bag sizers from boarding gates

    Qatar Airways Al Mourjan Business Lounge review: ‘It doesn’t get bigger than this…’

    Qatar Airways Al Mourjan Business Lounge review: ‘It doesn’t get bigger than this…’

    What is Bleach or Facial, Best for Skin?

    What is Bleach or Facial, Best for Skin?

    Tourists are flocking to a mind-bending Chinese megacity where Google Maps doesn’t work

    Tourists are flocking to a mind-bending Chinese megacity where Google Maps doesn’t work

    An ESTA change has just made travelling to America more expensive for Brits

    An ESTA change has just made travelling to America more expensive for Brits

    The best Maldives alternatives that are cheaper — and three are in Europe

    The best Maldives alternatives that are cheaper — and three are in Europe

    Italy strikes for Gaza: What tourists need to know amid travel disruption in Rome and Milan

    Italy strikes for Gaza: What tourists need to know amid travel disruption in Rome and Milan

    ‘Dystopian’ cruise ship divides travellers — and gives a glimpse into the future

    ‘Dystopian’ cruise ship divides travellers — and gives a glimpse into the future

    Airline launches flights from £9 to European hotspots including Majorca, Alicante and Seville

    Airline launches flights from £9 to European hotspots including Majorca, Alicante and Seville

    I feel like a stranger in the UK after 21 years abroad

    I feel like a stranger in the UK after 21 years abroad

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Health
  • Opinion
  • Science
  • Tech
  • Crypto
  • Travel
  • Real Estate
  • Sports
  • More
    • Press Release
UK Herald
No Result
View All Result

Dan Wootton and the growing UK right to privacy explained

by Justin Marsh
March 19, 2024
0
0
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterReddit


Why have the Mirror and Guardian both apologised and paid privacy damages to former GB News presenter Dan Wootton, many might wonder?

Their reports were true, and pertained to criminal allegations about a prominent right-wing media figure – so of huge interest to their readers. (Two police investigations against Wootton have since been discontinued.)

But the UK has a developing judge-made right to privacy which is creeping in its scope and which the publishers were fearful of having to argue against in the High Court.

It is the sort of story Wootton himself might have written in his time as a showbiz journalist at The Sun and News of the World, but which he now views to be beyond the pale (in what he admits is a major change of heart).

In 2018, Wootton wrote an article for The Sun with a headline describing actor Johnny Depp as a “wife-beater”. Depp sued for defamation and lost in 2020 when the judge ruled the article was “substantially true”.

In an apology written for his new Substack newsletter, Wootton said he now believes that Sun column was a breach of privacy that he regrets. And, whether the allegations were true or not, if such a column appeared today and Depp sued for breach of privacy he might well win.

Wootton’s argument that reporting by The Sun and Mirror breached his privacy centres around a February 2022 Supreme Court judgment that ruled news service Bloomberg breached the privacy of a businessman by publishing the contents of a confidential letter that revealed he was the subject of criminal complaint.

The court ruled that when someone is under criminal investigation they have a right to privacy until the point at which they are charged.

The UK law of privacy is judge-made because it is up to the courts to balance everyone’s right to privacy under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights versus journalists’ right to freedom of expression under Article 10. Any invasions of privacy must be justified in the public interest.

Why did The Sun, Mirror and others identify Wootton in the first place?

The Wootton case was different from Bloomberg because allegations against him had already been put in the public domain by Byline Times several months earlier and very widely discussed on social media.

Wootton himself then spoke about the allegations on GB News when he admitted to “errors of judgment” but said that “criminal allegations” against him were “simply untrue”.

In October 2023, Byline Times revealed that Wootton was the subject of a police investigation after this was confirmed by the Met Police.

College of Policing Guidelines state that the force cannot name suspects before charge in anything other than exceptional circumstances. But on this occasion, as with some other high-profile cases, the Met confirmed it was a conducting an investigation into an unnamed individual who journalists were then able to identify.

This revelation from Byline Times was repeated by The Mirror, Guardian, The National and numerous individuals on social media.

The publishers may have assumed it was safe to report on this breaking story because the fact that Wootton was subject to criminal allegations was already in the public domain and because the Met Police had confirmed he was under investigation.

Why have Sun and Mirror paid Wootton damages?

The Sun, Mirror and The National took their stories down after being contacted by a lawyer for Wootton who explicitly cited the Bloomberg precedent. Given that all the reporting on this story has been carried out by Byline Times, which reported extensively on the Wootton allegations, the other publishers may have decided that this was not their fight to win.

Byline Times may yet feel it has enough material to mount a public interest defence, but other publishers who followed the story up rather than backing it up with first-hand reporting might feel on shakier ground.

For the Mirror and Guardian, litigation fatigue may also be a factor. The Mirror is still engaged in wide-ranging and expensive legal actions related to hacking. The Guardian is fighting a £10m defamation claim from the actor Noel Clarke who was accused of sexual misconduct. Given the huge expense of fighting defamation and privacy actions where legal fees can run into the millions, publishers must be pragmatic about how many cases to take on.

The apologies from the Mirror and The Guardian were accompanied by contributions to costs believed to be in the order of low five figures.

Ultimately the Wootton case may lie in a grey area on privacy but it will be a risky and expensive point to prove for any publisher brave enough to take him to court. Byline Times has made no indication so far that it is prepared to settle.

Before Cliff Richard’s 2019 privacy win against the BBC it was not unusual for criminal suspects to be named at the point of arrest. This went on throughout the hacking scandal and Operation Elveden, for example, each time a new journalist was questioned by police.

Openness versus secrecy

Those who argue for openness fear secrecy around arrests and investigations could lead to less scrutiny of the police. Some are concerned about the prospect of people being arrested and being held at police stations with no public right to know what has happened to them.

The other argument in favour of disclosure is that secrecy could protect wrongdoers. There have been cases where publicity at the point of arrest has led to more victims coming forward.

In cases like Wootton, where allegations have been widely publicised, it could be argued that the public have a right to know that police are taking claims seriously. Wootton would, of course, still have recourse to a defamation action if accusations were untrue.

In Northern Ireland, those accused of sexual offences have anonymity up until the point of charge for their lifetime and 25 years after their death after new legislation was introduced last year. If this legislation had been force in the UK in 2012, Jimmy Savile’s crimes would still be secret.

Wootton says the allegations aired against him were untrue, denies doing anything criminal and feels his reputation has been unfairly tainted by the revelation he was under police investigation. His case is strengthened by the fact that two police forces decided not to charge him with any crime. Wootton says that he was set up and notes that no file was ever handed to police by the CPS.

But the case highlights the fact that we have a generally more cautious press, which is increasingly reluctant to put true stories into the public domain for fear of litigation.

The post Dan Wootton and the growing UK right to privacy explained appeared first on Press Gazette.



Source link

Related Posts

News diary 6-12 October: Labour deputy leader ballot opens, Greater Anglia trains nationalised, Nobel Prizes announced

by Justin Marsh
October 4, 2025
0

A look ahead at the key events leading the news agenda next week, from the team at Foresight News. Leading the week Monday (October 6): Shadow Chancellor Mel Stride delivers speech on...

Newsletter tips from the New York Times: Visuals, strong host, short, intimate

Newsletter tips from the New York Times: Visuals, strong host, short, intimate

by Justin Marsh
September 29, 2025
0

New York Times editorial director for newsletters Jodi Rudoren told Press Gazette what makes a good email update as the title launched a new daily edition. The World has a five-strong editorial...

Hearst UK losses grow as search changes hit digital ad revenue

Hearst UK losses grow as search changes hit digital ad revenue

by Justin Marsh
September 24, 2025
0

A second year of traffic turbulence led to continued revenue decline at Hearst UK in 2024, according to newly-filed accounts. Total revenue at National Magazine Company Ltd (the trading name of Hearst...

Journalist going to trial after highlighting porn shared by ex-MP on X

Journalist going to trial after highlighting porn shared by ex-MP on X

by Justin Marsh
September 19, 2025
0

Retired Brighton-based journalist Greg Hadfield will go to trial over drawing attention to an obscene X message posted by the account of former Labour MP Ivor Caplin. Hadfield applied for the court...

News diary 15-21 September: Trump visits UK, interest rate decision, sentencing of Constance Marten and Mark Gordon

News diary 15-21 September: Trump visits UK, interest rate decision, sentencing of Constance Marten and Mark Gordon

by Justin Marsh
September 14, 2025
0

The week ahead looks to be dominated by the visit of Donald Trump for the UK, as the US President arrives Tuesday and takes part in a State Banquet with King Charles...

Lifestyle brand Refinery29 closes UK office and lays off journalists

Lifestyle brand Refinery29 closes UK office and lays off journalists

by Justin Marsh
September 9, 2025
0

US-based digital media company Refinery29 has closed its UK operations and made an unknown number of company-wide cuts. The site’s output includes content on lifestyle, fashion, wellness, relationships and money. Its sub-brand...

Next Post
The London tourist attractions that have seen the biggest price hikes revealed

The London tourist attractions that have seen the biggest price hikes revealed

Popular News

Clive Lewis: ‘Robin Cook showed us politics at its most serious. Labour has lost that balance’

Clive Lewis: ‘Robin Cook showed us politics at its most serious. Labour has lost that balance’

October 8, 2025
Nobel Prize of Physics to 3 American Scientists for Energy Level Search

Nobel Prize of Physics to 3 American Scientists for Energy Level Search

October 7, 2025
Major airline removes carry-on bag sizers from boarding gates

Major airline removes carry-on bag sizers from boarding gates

October 7, 2025
Nobel Prize in Medicine for the discovery of 'Peripheral Immune Tolerance'

Nobel Prize in Medicine for the discovery of 'Peripheral Immune Tolerance'

October 6, 2025
Obama in London: Have Starmer and Labour already shown they were listening?

Obama in London: Have Starmer and Labour already shown they were listening?

October 6, 2025
Week-in-Review: The calling of Keir Starmer

Week-in-Review: The calling of Keir Starmer

October 4, 2025
Qatar Airways Al Mourjan Business Lounge review: ‘It doesn’t get bigger than this…’

Qatar Airways Al Mourjan Business Lounge review: ‘It doesn’t get bigger than this…’

October 4, 2025
UK Herald

All Rights Reserved © UK HERALD - The Voice of UK

Important Links

  • Publish Your article
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • Advertise

...

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • UK News
  • Business
  • Science
  • National
  • Entertainment
  • Gaming
  • Sports
  • Fashion
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Health
  • Food

All Rights Reserved © UK HERALD - The Voice of UK