• Publish Your article
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Friday, November 20, 2026
No Result
View All Result
UK Herald
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Sports
    England rugby stadium Twickenham given new name after more than 100 years in shock new deal

    England rugby stadium Twickenham given new name after more than 100 years in shock new deal

    Peter Morgan dead at 65: Former Wales and Lions rugby star who became a politician passes away as club pays tribute

    Peter Morgan dead at 65: Former Wales and Lions rugby star who became a politician passes away as club pays tribute

    Horse racing tips: Unexposed Group 1 contender can stun the big guns at 14-1

    Horse racing tips: Unexposed Group 1 contender can stun the big guns at 14-1

    Woman ‘raped seven times by two French rugby stars who left her riddled with bite marks & with horror injuries’

    Woman ‘raped seven times by two French rugby stars who left her riddled with bite marks & with horror injuries’

    Horse racing tips: Gary Moore’s charge can gain revenge after falling last time out

    Horse racing tips: Gary Moore’s charge can gain revenge after falling last time out

    Ian Buckett dead at 56: Former Wales rugby star who was ‘admired and feared equally’ dies as tributes pour in

    Ian Buckett dead at 56: Former Wales rugby star who was ‘admired and feared equally’ dies as tributes pour in

    Horse racing tips: Bash the bookies with these longshots including 9-1 fancy

    Horse racing tips: Bash the bookies with these longshots including 9-1 fancy

    Shayne Philpott dead at 58 – New Zealand All Blacks rugby legend dies after suffering ‘medical event’

    Shayne Philpott dead at 58 – New Zealand All Blacks rugby legend dies after suffering ‘medical event’

    Horse racing tips: This 7-1 chance appears to have been laid out for race he won last year

    Horse racing tips: This 7-1 chance appears to have been laid out for race he won last year

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • food
    • Health
    • Travel
    Londoners are sick of the ‘uncomfortable’ elbow game Tube passengers keep playing

    Londoners are sick of the ‘uncomfortable’ elbow game Tube passengers keep playing

    Welsh island Prince William calls ‘magical’ is ‘the most underrated place in the world’

    Welsh island Prince William calls ‘magical’ is ‘the most underrated place in the world’

    What you get for £180,000 per person in the round-the-world Four Seasons holiday

    What you get for £180,000 per person in the round-the-world Four Seasons holiday

    Spain travel warning as flights and trains to face worst disruption in 14 years

    Spain travel warning as flights and trains to face worst disruption in 14 years

    Warning as hugely popular Greek tourist destination set for city-wide shutdown

    Warning as hugely popular Greek tourist destination set for city-wide shutdown

    Iconic Greek holiday island should prepare for possible tsunami, seismologist warns

    Iconic Greek holiday island should prepare for possible tsunami, seismologist warns

    First major change to London bus fare prices since 2023 comes into effect

    First major change to London bus fare prices since 2023 comes into effect

    Inside the ‘endless cruise’ disaster as OAPs left homeless in Cambodia

    Inside the ‘endless cruise’ disaster as OAPs left homeless in Cambodia

    Ryanair flight to Bristol forced to divert almost 1,000 miles to Spain in Storm Boelo

    Ryanair flight to Bristol forced to divert almost 1,000 miles to Spain in Storm Boelo

    Londoners are divided over the ‘terrifying’ Tube escalator causing ‘hallucinations’

    Londoners are divided over the ‘terrifying’ Tube escalator causing ‘hallucinations’

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Health
  • Opinion
  • Science
  • Tech
  • Crypto
  • Travel
  • Real Estate
  • Sports
  • More
    • Press Release
UK Herald
No Result
View All Result

A legal anomaly is costing the NHS billions

by Justin Marsh
March 19, 2026
0
0
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterReddit


The NHS is one of Britain’s most cherished institutions, providing care to millions of patients each year. Yet questions remain about whether every resource is directed towards its core purpose of treating patients. One example is a law predating the NHS that requires it to pay out vast sums each year for private treatment that may never be used.

This is the real-world consequence of an obscure provision: Section 2(4) of the Law Reform (Personal Injuries) Act 1948.

The provision requires courts, when awarding compensation for clinical negligence, to disregard NHS care and assume the claimant will use private healthcare. Yet nothing in law obliges the claimant to do so. Someone injured through negligence may receive compensation for private treatment but still return to the NHS – effectively charging the NHS twice. Repealing this provision would not force claimants to automatically return to the NHS for their future care. Rather, it would allow courts to decide what is reasonable in each case.

The Act was introduced to modernise personal injury law. Yet unlike many other legacies of the Attlee ggovernment, this change has failed to stand the test of time. Much of the Act has since been repealed or replaced. The survival of Section 2(4) is therefore all the more puzzling.

When Section 2(4) was drafted, the NHS was only just being established, and the healthcare landscape looked very different. Private treatment was more common, and the idea of a universal health service untested, so the provision could be justified. In today’s world, it no longer makes sense.

In practice, courts must calculate the cost of private treatment even when the claimant has no intention of using it, and even when equivalent NHS services are available. This inflates settlements and creates a financial burden that falls on the public purse. Every pound spent here is a pound diverted from frontline healthcare.

The problem has been recognised for decades. In 1973, a Royal Commission – commonly known as the Pearson Commission – examined the issue and recommended repealing Section 2(4) when it reported in 1978, warning of the risk of double payment. But by then Jim Callaghan was in Downing Street without a workable majority, and the proposal went nowhere.

Calls for repeal persisted. The matter resurfaced repeatedly in parliament, and in the 1990s Rosie Barnes introduced a private member’s bill to abolish the provision, backed by figures including Tony Blair, Jeremy Corbyn and Charles Kennedy. Like most such bills, it ultimately failed to progress.

Today the stakes are even higher. The current clinical negligence framework – including Section 2(4) – is contributing to spiralling costs. In 2024/25 the NHS in England spent £3.6 billion on clinical negligence, according to the latest National Audit Office (NAO) report. This figure is projected to exceed £4 billion a year by the end of the decade. Patients harmed by negligence must receive appropriate compensation, but it’s difficult to deny that our current system is costing more than necessary, in part because of this law.

Escalating costs have brought renewed attention to Section 2(4). Late last year, the National Audit Office recommended re-examining the provision. The public accounts committee followed in January, urging the government to set out within six months what legislative steps it will take to address this outdated law.

Support is also growing across the political spectrum. Since the General Election, MPs and peers from Labour, the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats have raised questions about the provision’s future. The tide is clearly turning in favour of reform.

This week a bill introduced by Catherine McKinnell will directly address Section 2(4) as part of a wider package of clinical negligence reforms. It is the first such legislation in years, and parliament should seize the opportunity.

With cross-party support, authoritative reports and legislation now before parliament, the question is simple: why not act now?

Politics.co.uk is the UK’s leading digital-only political website. Subscribe to our daily newsletter for all the latest news and analysis.

The post A legal anomaly is costing the NHS billions appeared first on Politics.co.uk.



Source link

Related Posts

PMQs verdict: Burnham takes on the Brexit ‘zombies’

PMQs verdict: Burnham takes on the Brexit ‘zombies’

by Justin Marsh
November 18, 2026
0

Prime minister’s questions today was one of those rare sessions when the most revealing exchange came after the leader of the opposition, Kemi Badenoch, returned to her seat on the Conservative frontbench....

Tracker: the Labour MPs opposed to Rosebank oilfield as rebellion mounts

Tracker: the Labour MPs opposed to Rosebank oilfield as rebellion mounts

by Justin Marsh
November 16, 2026
0

Andy Burnham faces growing unease among Labour MPs over the Rosebank oilfield, with the prospect of a backbench revolt and even resignations if it is approved. Dozens of Labour MPs have publicly...

Rishi Sunak re-selected as Conservative candidate for next general election

Rishi Sunak re-selected as Conservative candidate for next general election

by Justin Marsh
November 14, 2026
0

Rishi Sunak has been readopted as the Conservative candidate in Richmond and Northallerton, the seat he has represented since 2015. The former prime minister thanked local members in a post on X...

‘Shame!’: Row erupts after Tugendhat accuses minister of ‘siding with Hamas’

‘Shame!’: Row erupts after Tugendhat accuses minister of ‘siding with Hamas’

by Justin Marsh
November 12, 2026
0

Tom Tugendhat has been accused of a “disgraceful slur” in the House of Commons after he suggested a government minister was “siding with Hamas”.  The shadow foreign secretary was responding to a...

Lib Dem MP brings ‘St George’s bill’ to add Black English and Asian English to census

Lib Dem MP brings ‘St George’s bill’ to add Black English and Asian English to census

by Justin Marsh
November 10, 2026
0

Liberal Democrat president Josh Babarinde has brought a cross-party bill to the House of Commons that would broaden the range of ethnicity options in the census, enabling Britons to define themselves as...

Burnham’s case for rejoining the EU rests on invented narratives, not facts

Burnham’s case for rejoining the EU rests on invented narratives, not facts

by Justin Marsh
November 8, 2026
0

The prime minister argues that leaving the EU has caused permanent harm to the economy. His whole case is founded on invented narratives. It is based on pure conjecture: on what some...

Next Post
US publishers see traffic boost for breaking news from Google Discover

US publishers see traffic boost for breaking news from Google Discover

Popular News

Remembering Kia’s first EV, which led a marathon 40 years ago

Remembering Kia’s first EV, which led a marathon 40 years ago

November 19, 2026
Londoners are sick of the ‘uncomfortable’ elbow game Tube passengers keep playing

Londoners are sick of the ‘uncomfortable’ elbow game Tube passengers keep playing

November 19, 2026
PMQs verdict: Burnham takes on the Brexit ‘zombies’

PMQs verdict: Burnham takes on the Brexit ‘zombies’

November 18, 2026
Tracker: the Labour MPs opposed to Rosebank oilfield as rebellion mounts

Tracker: the Labour MPs opposed to Rosebank oilfield as rebellion mounts

November 16, 2026
Motoring Research on the Motoring Podcast! A new source of car reviews

Motoring Research on the Motoring Podcast! A new source of car reviews

November 16, 2026
Welsh island Prince William calls ‘magical’ is ‘the most underrated place in the world’

Welsh island Prince William calls ‘magical’ is ‘the most underrated place in the world’

November 16, 2026
Rishi Sunak re-selected as Conservative candidate for next general election

Rishi Sunak re-selected as Conservative candidate for next general election

November 14, 2026
UK Herald

All Rights Reserved © UK HERALD - The Voice of UK

Important Links

  • Publish Your article
  • Editorial Policy
  • Contact
  • Advertise

...

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • UK News
  • Business
  • Science
  • National
  • Entertainment
  • Gaming
  • Sports
  • Fashion
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Health
  • Food

All Rights Reserved © UK HERALD - The Voice of UK