Andy Burnham faces growing unease among Labour MPs over the Rosebank oilfield, with the prospect of a backbench revolt and even resignations if it is approved.
Dozens of Labour MPs have publicly voiced opposition or concern over the Rosebank oilfield. Politics.co.uk analysis of public statements and parliamentary debates found that almost 50 MPs have raised objections in recent months, including six ministerial aides.
Rosebank, situated 80 miles north-west of Shetland, is Britain’s largest remaining untapped oil field.
The government is under pressure from the Conservative Party and some Labour MPs to approve Rosebank. Speaking at prime minister’s questions last week, Andy Burnham said the government would “take a further decision on Rosebank in due course, as well as building a renewable energy future.”
It comes after energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh approved plans for drilling at the Jackdaw gas field near Aberdeen last month.
While the Guardian reports that Fahnbulleh is minded to reject Rosebank, she could be overruled. The cabinet is said to be split over the proposal, with chancellor John Healey in favour. A private letter to Burnham opposing the project had been signed by 75 Labour MPs, according to the Sunday Times. The Guardian reports it could reach 100.
Concerns over Rosebank have been building for months.
An early day motion (EDM) tabled in June recorded the opposition of several Labour MPs. The motion, spearheaded by Clive Lewis, called on the government “to reject Rosebank and prioritise investment in a clean energy transition that supports workers, communities and future generations.”
Meanwhile, 25 Labour MPs have reportedly signed the “Stop Rosebank Pledge”, which is described by campaigners as a way for “politicians to publicly show their opposition to the Rosebank oil field and their support for a just transition.”
Labour MPs have also declared their opposition to Rosebank on several occasions in parliament. These include an opposition day debate on oil and gas on 24 March, an urgent question on Jackdaw and Rosebank on 3 September, energy department questions on 13 October, the ministerial statement approving the Jackdaw gasfield on 21 October, and a Westminster Hall debate on 11 November.
In Westminster Hall last Wednesday, a total of 18 Labour MPs voiced opposition or concern regarding the possible approval of the Rosebank oilfield. (Perran Moon, an independent MP with the Labour whip suspended, also spoke against it.)
Among the Labour MPs who spoke against Rosebank in Westminster Hall were three parliamentary private secretaries (PPSs) at the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, namely Anna Gelderd, Laura Kyrke-Smith and Chris Murray.
Three further PPSs backed the “Rosebank oil field” EDM tabled in June, namely Olivia Blake, Steve Witherden and Mary Kelly Foy. Blake was one of the motion’s six sponsors, and she and Witherden, a PPS in the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, have also signed the “Stop Rosebank” pledge.
During the Westminster Hall debate, energy minister Michael Shanks reiterated that Rosebank is “subject to an ongoing regulatory process”.
He added: “In due course, the secretary of state for energy has to decide whether or not to agree the grant of that consent… I stress that this government will not make decisions for this country that are not compatible with our climate obligations.”
Some Labour MPs also voiced support for approving Rosebank, including Luke Akehurst, Jonathan Brash, Graeme Downie and Al Carns.
Each of the Labour MPs listed below has voiced opposition or concern over Rosebank on the record in recent months. This page will be updated as more Labour parliamentarians make their views known.
Last updated: Monday 16 November 2026, 18:02
Labour MPs who have publicly voiced concern or opposition: 45 (excluding Perran Moon)
- Andrew Lewin (Welwyn Hatfield)
“Our government has a strong record of investment in clean and green energy. Approving Rosebank risks undermining our own climate leadership. It is not worth it.
“Some advocates for Rosebank argue it is worth higher emissions for higher tax revenues. I don’t agree.
“The North sea is a declining basin and the OBR said in October that even if Rosebank is approved, tax revenues from oil and gas will fall to nearly zero by 2031.
“For the Rosebank field itself, tax revenue raised would be less than 0.1% of total annual UK tax receipts.
“Despite the very small tax revenues, we risk paying a high political price with voters who want to continue to see climate leadership from a Labour government.
“Let’s say no to Rosebank and keep our focus on our programme of investment in renewable energy and updates to the grid.”
Statement to Politics.co.uk, 16 November.
- Chris Hinchliff (North East Hertfordshire)
“If we measure both sides of the scales, it is obvious that the costs of pollution from Rosebank vastly outweigh any of its benefits.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Sponsor of ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Simon Opher (Stroud)
“Does she [Liberal Democrat spokesperson Pippa Heylings] agree with me, and about 150 constituents who have written to me, that instead of investing in the exploration of oilfields such as Rosebank, which would cost £4.1 billion – it is a difficult field to explore – and would not lower bills, we should invest £4.1 billion in renewable energy?”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Sponsor of ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Rachael Maskell (York Central)
“Rosebank will have a direct consequence for climate destruction and human life. It will impact trust in government and weaken our global standing as leaders in climate protection.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Cat Eccles (Stourbridge)
“Does the honourable lady [Conservative spokesperson Harriet Cross] recognise that any oil extracted from Rosebank would have to be exported to be refined? We do not have the refining capacity, as she just mentioned, so it would represent more carbon emissions, increased costs and very little coming back to us.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Cat Smith (Lancaster and Wyre)
“I urge the government to listen to my constituents and to recognise how unpopular a decision it would be to go ahead with the Rosebank development.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Bell Ribeiro-Addy (Clapham and Brixton Hill)
“Does the honourable member [Green MP Carla Denyer] agree that those nations did the least to cause this crisis, but are already paying for it in floods, failed harvests and debt, and that Britain should not hand the global south yet another bill for our choices?”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Richard Burgon (Leeds East)
“Whatever else they do on the environment, getting Rosebank wrong will shape the green credentials of this government for years to come… For so many reasons, the government must not approve Rosebank.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
“I am incredibly disappointed in today’s decision on Jackdaw; I believe that it flies in the face of all the evidence and will do nothing to lower people’s energy bills, create jobs or improve our energy security… can [the minister] confirm that today’s decision in no way implies or means that the approval of Rosebank will automatically follow?”
Commons statement on Jackdaw, 21 October.
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Joe Morris (Hexham)
“Drilling at Rosebank would be a mistake for our climate goals and it would not accomplish the very things that many voices arguing in favour of it claim it would… I want us to be the government who have the courage to say no to Rosebank.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
- Apsana Begum (Poplar and Limehouse)
“Like many of my constituents, I am alarmed at the suggestion of even more carbon extraction from the North sea.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
- Abtisam Mohamed (Sheffield Central)
“Rosebank fails on every test. It will not benefit taxpayers, who will shoulder the vast majority of the development costs. It will not strengthen our energy security, because most of the oil will be sold on international markets.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Chris Murray (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) – PPS in the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office
“I oppose Rosebank because I back Scotland’s energy sector and I want it to thrive for decades to come.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Julia Buckley (Shrewsbury)
“I would urge the minister and our secretary of state not to make a decision in favour of Rosebank and not to add further to our climate emergency.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
- John Whitby (Derbyshire Dales)
“On Rosebank, we cannot keep kicking this planet-sized can down the road. We need to draw the line somewhere – and I say we draw it here.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
- Samantha Niblett (South Derbyshire)
“Does my honourable friend [Whitby] agree that saying we contribute only 1% to global emissions does not give weight to the size of our influence? We might be small, but we are mighty. If we are flippant about our commitment to renewables and reducing our carbon emissions, that sends an awful message to the rest of the world.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
- Perran Moon (Camborne and Redruth) – sitting as independent after Labour whip suspended
“I was proud to be elected on a manifesto that pledged to ban the approval of new oil and gas licences in the North sea. Rosebank would be a futile final bone thrown to the oil industry.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
- Laura Kyrke-Smith (Aylesbury) – PPS in the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office
“The wider context of the Rosebank decision is clear and cannot be stated firmly enough. The route to a clean, secure and affordable future lies in renewable energy, not in more drilling of oil and gas…
“I do not see the energy security case for Rosebank. In the short term, it will not boost our domestic energy production, as 90% of its reserves are oil, not gas, and are likely to be exported. In the long term, it will drive up emissions and increase the very real security threats caused by climate change, from pressure on food systems to increased migration.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
- Anna Gelderd (South East Cornwall) – PPS in the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office
“We live in an unprecedented era in which our energy security is more vital than ever and in which jobs and wealth must be protected and economic opportunities seized. On both of those points, Rosebank fails.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
- Rupa Huq (Ealing Central and Acton)
“We all want growth but, given that Rosebank is primarily for export and that oil and gas revenues are expected to plummet to nearly zero by 2030, does the honourable member [Carla Denyer] agree that even the economic case does not stack up?”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
- Helen Hayes (Dulwich and West Norwood)
“My constituents care deeply about the climate emergency, they want to see fossil fuels remain in the ground, they want there to be no drilling at Rosebank, and they want to see our government continuing to lead on the global stage on the energy transition.”
Westminster Hall debate, 11 November.
“The decision on Jackdaw has been taken in the context of communities across the country meeting to watch screenings of the ‘National Emergency Briefing’ on climate change… It would be very difficult to watch the film and conclude, for example, that drilling in the Rosebank oilfield should be allowed to go ahead.”
Commons statement on Jackdaw, 21 October.
- Clive Lewis (Norwich South)
“You cannot claim global climate leadership while approving new oilfields simply because you’ve already pencilled in the tax receipts. Tax ‘receipts’, as I understand it, that will be the operator’s estimate and not actual Treasury revenue.”
Guardian report, 29 October.
Primary sponsor of ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Catherine Fookes (Monmouthshire) – member of the energy security and net zero select committee
“Approving Rosebank will blow a hole in our green credentials. A group of us is making it clear to leadership that this should be Miatta’s decision and I hope they listen. Labour MPs are really, really concerned about it – it would go against the thrust of our manifesto.”
Guardian report, 29 October.
“I am afraid I do not agree with drilling for oil in Rosebank. It would not take a penny off bills, and it would absolutely blow our carbon emissions targets out the water.”
Commons urgent question on Jackdaw and Rosebank, 3 September.
- Stella Creasy (Walthamstow)
“The minister will know that the climate science is clear that opening any new North sea oil and gasfields is incompatible with achieving our Paris climate agreement goal of limiting warming to 1.5°C. He will know that Jackdaw alone is worth 35 million tonnes of carbon dioxide, and Rosebank a further 250 million tonnes.”
Commons statement on Jackdaw, 21 October.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- John McDonnell (Hayes and Harlington)
“Will the minister take into discussions with colleagues my concern that approvals in the decision-making process for Rosebank and/or a third runway at Heathrow, could permanently damage our environmental credentials?”
Commons statement on Jackdaw, 21 October.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Josh Dean (Hertford and Stortford)
“Countless constituents have written to me setting out their concern – a concern that I share – about this decision and a potential decision on Rosebank.”
Commons statement on Jackdaw, 21 October.
- Chris Ward (Brighton Kemptown and Peacehaven)
“I am concerned about the message this decision sends about how serious we are about tackling the climate emergency and protecting our hard-won international reputation as a world leader on climate change. However, I am even more concerned – as are my constituents – that this is a prelude to the bigger decision on Rosebank that is to come.”
Commons statement on Jackdaw, 21 October.
- Scott Arthur (Edinburgh South West)
“However, to some extent, Jackdaw is just a sideshow because it is really Rosebank that many people are concerned about. Will the Minister confirm that despite media speculation, the decision today will not set a precedent for Rosebank and that it will be judged on its own merits or otherwise?”
Commons statement on Jackdaw, 21 October.
- Fleur Anderson (Putney)
“Many of my constituents in Putney have written to me about this. They are very concerned about Rosebank’s lifetime emissions, which are equivalent to 254 million tonnes of CO2… Can the minister tell me whether approving Rosebank is compatible with the UK’s climate targets and obligations under the Paris agreement?”
Commons energy questions, 13 October.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Afzal Khan (Manchester Rusholme)
“I am proud to stand behind a government who are taking climate action seriously. However, we are already overshooting critical limits, and climate change will only get worse if we do not stop burning fossil fuels.
“Will the full direct climate impact of Rosebank and the implications of the international community’s efforts to transition away from fossil fuels be considered in making this decision?”
Commons energy questions, 13 October.
- Kerry McCarthy (Bristol East)
“Personally, I cannot see that Rosebank is compatible with meeting our climate objectives, but I recognise that the process should be followed.”
Commons urgent question on Jackdaw and Rosebank, 3 September.
- Mike Reader (Northampton South) – member of the energy security and net zero select committee
“The evidence is clear, approving Rosebank and Jackdaw will not protect jobs. The sector is unfortunately in decline.”
Commons urgent question on Jackdaw and Rosebank, 3 September.
“To be clear, I fiercely oppose further oil and gas exploration in the North sea… Modelling on Rosebank and ending the energy profits levy shows that there could be a net loss of about £250 million to the Treasury, while operators would receive about £1.5 billion in profits. That should give us pause for thought.”
Commons opposition day debate on oil and gas, 24 March.
- Olivia Blake (Sheffield Hallam) – PPS in the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
Sponsor of ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Steve Witherden (Montgomeryshire and Glyndŵr) – PPS in the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Alex Sobel (Leeds Central and Headingley)
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Ian Byrne (Liverpool West Derby)
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Diane Abbott (Hackney North and Stoke Newington)
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Neil Duncan-Jordan (Poole)
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Nadia Whittome (Nottingham East)
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
- Kim Johnson (Liverpool Riverside)
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
- Mary Kelly Foy (City of Durham) – PPS to Matthew Pennycook, minister of state for housing and planning
Signed ‘Rosebank oil field’ EDM, tabled 8 June.
- Sadik Al-Hassan (North Somerset)
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Kate Osamor (Edmonton and Winchmore Hill)
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Jon Trickett (Normanton and Hemsworth)
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Dawn Butler (Brent East)
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Brian Leishman (Alloa and Grangemouth)
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
- Anna Dixon (Shipley)
Signed ‘Stop Rosebank’ pledge.
The post Tracker: the Labour MPs opposed to Rosebank oilfield as rebellion mounts appeared first on Politics.co.uk.





























