
The Scottish Government has ordered an urgent and fully independent review into how warnings about liver and pancreatic surgery at NHS Grampian were handled, after a whistleblowing surgeon made public a report that found 19 patients had died avoidable deaths.
Health Secretary Angela Constance announced the review on Saturday, two days after Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, released the unpublished 2022 document at a press conference in Glasgow and called for a corporate homicide investigation.
The review will examine the conduct of both the health board and the Scottish Government, including how repeated letters from Dr Habib to ministers were dealt with.
What the 2022 report found
The report was commissioned by NHS Grampian and carried out by two external experts, Professor Stephen Wigmore and Professor Giles Toogood. They examined 45 cases of hepato-pancreato-biliary (HPB) surgery, which treats the liver, pancreas, gallbladder and bile ducts, between 2015 and 2021. Of those patients, 31 had died. The reviewers concluded that 19 had died of avoidable consequences of surgery or intervention, according to a timeline compiled by the Herald.
The review pointed to recurring problems with leadership, decision-making, pre-operative planning and surgical technique. Dr Habib has also said two patients died after having the wrong procedure, and that the true number of avoidable deaths could run to “several dozen”.
The surgeon says he contacted the Scottish Government on four separate occasions, as well as Police Scotland and the Lord Advocate. Police Scotland’s Major Investigations Team North has been looking at his concerns since early 2024. First Minister John Swinney has ordered a separate review of how government correspondence is handled, after saying he only learned on Thursday of three letters Dr Habib had sent him.
What the review will cover
Ms Constance said the allegations were “deeply concerning and of the utmost seriousness”. “Following discussion with the first minister, I am today commissioning an urgent and fully independent review of how concerns about hepatobiliary (HPB) surgery in NHS Grampian was handled, including the 2022 report into the deaths of patients who underwent HPB surgery,” she said, as reported by the BBC.
She said it would identify weaknesses in governance, missed opportunities, unreasonable delay and gaps in accountability. The government has said any issues, including possible criminality, will be referred to the relevant authorities as they arise, without waiting for a final report.
NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight said the board would be “open and transparent” in co-operating, and that it would take immediate steps to secure and preserve relevant files and records.
Humza Yousaf, who was health secretary when the 2022 report was completed, said through a spokesperson that he supported “full transparency about what happened at NHS Grampian” and would co-operate fully with any review.
Political pressure at Holyrood
Opposition parties welcomed the review but pressed for answers on who knew what and when. Scottish Labour health spokeswoman Jackie Baillie said grieving families deserved “the full truth of what happened at the health board, including who knew what was going on, when they knew, and why it has taken this long for these concerns to come to light”.
Scottish Conservative health spokesman Miles Briggs said the review must not become a “vehicle to shirk responsibility”, while Liberal Democrat MSP Yi-pei Chou Turvey described the wait for answers as “excruciating” for families.
The row follows a damning Healthcare Improvement Scotland review of NHS Grampian’s leadership and culture, which Ms Constance responded to at Holyrood on Tuesday. The same day she appointed an external team of senior NHS leaders to provide “intensive turnaround support” to the board. Ms Constance told BBC Radio Scotland on Friday that she still had confidence in Ms Skaife-Knight, because many of the problems predate her appointment, the Scotsman reported.
What it means for patients and UK readers
Complex liver and pancreatic surgery has been suspended at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary since January, and Whipple procedures, a major pancreatic operation, were moved to Edinburgh at the end of 2024. Patients in the north east who need these operations are already being treated elsewhere.
The Scottish Government has urged anyone with questions about their own or a relative’s care to call the NHS Grampian helpline on 08085 202030.
Beyond Scotland, the case is likely to renew debate across the UK’s health services about how whistleblowers are protected and whether ministers can be relied on to act when warnings reach them.
What happens next
Ms Constance will make a statement at Holyrood on Tuesday, when she is expected to set out the review’s timetable and name who will lead it. Dr Habib and his solicitor, Aamer Anwar, have called for a statutory public inquiry, for all bereaved families to be told whether their relatives’ deaths were examined, and for NHS Grampian to be placed under the highest level of government intervention.























